Do you mean if we could get either A or B , or do you mean which one we liked more ? There are a lot more games in A than in B, how are we supposed to compare ?and in 4. B I think you mean Seasons, not episodes BTW, I think this should be a game like:You say: GTA 4 vs. GTA 2I say: GTA 4Then I make a new suggestion likeCrysis vs. Far Cryetc. Present versus Past
I choose B for 2.
i dont understand this. how can you be comparing gta 1 and 2 vs gta sa and 4?naturally the second option is better (and more expensive) so budget clearly isnt the issue, i dont understand ur dilemma
[QUOTE=''Darth_Kane'']Do you mean if we could get either A or B , or do you mean which one we liked more ? There are a lot more games in A than in B, how are we supposed to compare ?and in 4. B I think you mean Seasons, not episodes BTW, I think this should be a game like:You say: GTA 4 vs. GTA 2I say: GTA 4Then I make a new suggestion likeCrysis vs. Far Cryetc. [/QUOTE] 1)I corrected my mistake related with Sam and Max.2)You can interpret the question however you like.3)Your idea is a good one. But maybe we should generate a new topic for that.
1. A2. A3. Don't care4. A5. Don't care6. A7. A8. A9. B I prefer the older games.
[QUOTE=''jpph'']i dont understand this. how can you be comparing gta 1 and 2 vs gta sa and 4?naturally the second option is better (and more expensive) so budget clearly isnt the issue, i dont understand ur dilemma [/QUOTE] Some nostalgic people may prefer gta 1%262 over gta sa%264 same way they prefer daggerfall over oblivion.
1)B but not by much because Oblivion exponentially drags the rest down 2)B and I might add Heroes of Might and Magic V + expansions ;)3) none, gave up on them a long time ago4)A5)don't care6)B + ETQW and Team Fortress 2 (too bad Quake 3 wouldn't fit here) 7)B8 )neither, Grid and Trackmania United Forever9)B10) A: Quake 3, Wolfenstein 3D, Doom 2, Clive Barker's Undying B: Quake 4, Return to Castle Wolfenstein, Doom 3, Dead Space (or something like that)
Those comparisons suck tbh, and are biased towards the older games. You make it seem as if there are no adventure games other Sam %26 Max these days, your first person shooter comparison is like from 92 to 98 and then from 2007+, missing the greatest years of the genre (and you didnt even include STALKER!), the racing genre is so much more than Carmageddon and the latest Need for Speed, etc.It should look like this:
A- Doom, Quake1%262, Hexen1%262, Duke Nukem 3D, Blood, Dark Forces 2 B- NOLF1%262, Unreal Tournament, Quake 3, Half-Life, Undying, Deux Ex, System Shock 2, Tribes 2 C- FEAR, Crysis, STALKER, Unreal Tournament 2004, Half-Life 2, Tribes: Vengeance, PainkillerStill missing tactical shooters though (I missed the genre completely, will catch up soon, I promise), so whatever, the concept is hard to pull off properly.
[QUOTE=''ReddestSkies'']Those comparisons suck tbh, and are biased towards the older games. You make it seem as if there are no adventure games other Sam %26 Max these days, your first person shooter comparison is like from 92 to 98 and then from 2007+, missing the greatest years of the genre (and you didnt even include STALKER!), the racing genre is so much more than Carmageddon and the latest Need for Speed, etc.It should look like this:
A- Doom, Quake1%262, Hexen1%262, Duke Nukem 3D, Blood, Dark Forces 2 B- NOLF1%262, Unreal Tournament, Quake 3, Half-Life, Undying, Deux Ex, System Shock 2, Tribes 2 C- FEAR, Crysis, STALKER, Unreal Tournament 2004, Half-Life 2, Tribes: Vengeance, PainkillerStill missing tactical shooters though (I missed the genre completely, will catch up soon, I promise), so whatever, the concept is hard to pull off properly. [/QUOTE] I didnt promise a complete and unbiased comparison. Tried to put the greatest games I can think of together. (maybe late 90s against recent games)
- A
- A
- (don't care)
- A
- B
- A
- A
- (don't care)
- (neither, where's Vice City?)
B. Oblivion + The Witcher + Mass Effect + Fallout 3
2. A. Starcraft + AoE II + Red Alert + Total Annihilation + Heroes of Might %26 Magic III + Commandos 2 + Dungeon Keeper + Theme Hospital
B. Fifa 09 + NBA 2K9
Not fair - I love Adventure games but I'd have to go with; 4. A. Grim Fandango + The Curse of Monkey Island + The Neverhood + Sanitarium - even though I am currently playing Sam %26 Max S2
NEITHER
B. Crysis + Call of Duty 4 + Far Cry 2
B. Bioshock
8. A. Carmageddon - I loved this game!
Don't like GTA at all
All B , except 4 A
1.A. Daggerfall + Baldur's Gate II + Diablo + Icewind Dale + Fallout 2 + Planescape Torment + Might %26 Magic VI B. Oblivion + The Witcher + Mass Effect + Fallout 3 A (Huge Huge Margin)2. A. Starcraft + AoE II + Red Alert + Total Annihilation + Heroes of Might %26 Magic III + Commandos 2 + Dungeon Keeper + Theme Hospital B. Company of Heroes + World in Conflict + C%26C 3 + Supreme Commander +Medieval Total War IIA (Huge Margin)4. A. Grim Fandango + The Curse of Monkey Island + The Neverhood + Sanitarium B. Sam %26 Max Seasons 1%262 A (Huge Huge Margin)5. A.Ultima Online B.WOWB 6. A. Doom + Quake II + Blood + Heretic + Doom II + Duke Nuke'm + Outlaws B. Crysis + Call of Duty 4 + Far Cry 2A ( but could have been equal if you but better recent fps like stalker : cs, ob etc)7. A. System Shock 2 B. Bioshock A ( again huge margin )9. A. GTA 1%262 B. GTA SA + GTA IVB (although dislike both)10. A. SS2/ Deus Ex B. Bioshock/ Stalker CSA
1- A2- B3- None4- A5- None6- ... tough one... I'll go with B7- A8- None9- B
1. A easily.2. A easily.3. B (don't see why not).4. A5. A6. A if by Duke Nukem, you mean Duke Nukem 3d.7. A.8. A.9. B
No comments:
Post a Comment